中国科技期刊研究 ›› 2016, Vol. 27 ›› Issue (9): 938-942. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.201605040377

• 质量建设 • 上一篇    下一篇

专家审稿意见在科技期刊论文中的合理呈现探讨

李瑛   

  1. 巢湖学院文学传媒与教育科学学院,安徽省巢湖市半汤路1号 238024
  • 收稿日期:2016-05-04 修回日期:2016-08-21 出版日期:2016-09-15 发布日期:2016-09-15
  • 作者简介:李 瑛(ORCID:0000-0003-3885-7272),博士,教授,E-mail: mx201099@126.com

Analysis on the reasonable show ing of expert reviewers'comments in scientific papers

LI Ying   

  1. Literature Media and Education Science Institute of Chaohu College, 1Bantang Road Chaohu, Chaohu 238024, China
  • Received:2016-05-04 Revised:2016-08-21 Online:2016-09-15 Published:2016-09-15

摘要:

目的】揭示专家审稿意见在科技期刊论文中合理呈现的价值、形式和基本要求,为其深度开发利用提供借鉴。【方法】从科技期刊中充分搜集呈现专家审稿意见的例文,并参考相关研究成果,分析对比,总结归纳。【结果】发现纸质期刊随文刊载专家审稿意见并不普遍;主要分布于脚注和文后注释中,正文中较为罕见;形式上多为笼统致谢,具体描述专家审稿意见及本人处理情况的不多。【结论】专家审稿意见的合理呈现具有可行性和必要性,对其普及和推行有利于形成新的学术规范,加强审稿规范化,完善审稿机制,提高科技期刊利益各方的学术水平,推动学术繁荣。

关键词: 专家审稿意见, 科技期刊, 随文呈现, 呈现价值, 呈现形式, 基本要求

Abstract:

[Purposes]This paper aims to reveal the value, forms and basic requirements of the reasonable show ing of expert reviewers'comments in scientific papers,and provide a reference for its depth exploitation.[Methods]The author fully collected some examples from scientific journals, and referred to some researches, analyzed and compared thesematerials by review ing and summarizing them.[Findings]It is not common for the published expert reviewers'comments in papery journals.They aremainly distributed in the footnotes and endnotes of the paper, almost not in the main body of the paper.In the form of expression, they were generally expressing thankfulness mostly,and rarely specifically described the expert reviewers'comments and the author'processing.[Conclusions]The reasonable show ing of expert reviewers'comments is feasible and necessary.It can form new academ ic standards to popularize and promote them,promote the reviewers'normalization,improve themechanism of peer review,improve the academ ic level of the journals in all aspects,and promote academic prosperity.

Key words: Expert reviewers'comments, Scientific journal, Published in paper, Published value, Published form, Basic requirements