中国科技期刊研究 ›› 2019, Vol. 30 ›› Issue (8): 812-818.doi: 10.11946/cjstp.201903140167

• 论坛 • 上一篇    下一篇

期刊评价功能的异化、析因与回归

胡绍君1,)2)   

  1. 1) 南京大学信息管理学院,江苏省南京市栖霞区仙林大道163号 210023
    2) 东北石油大学图书馆,黑龙江省大庆市高新区学府街99号 163318
  • 收稿日期:2019-03-14 修回日期:2019-05-25 出版日期:2019-08-15 发布日期:2019-08-30
  • 作者简介:胡绍君(ORCID:0000-0002-1057-9787),博士研究生,副研究馆员,E-mail: hushaojun2004@126.com

Alienation, causes, and regression of journal evaluation function

HU Shaojun1,)2)   

  1. 1) School of Information Management, Nanjing University, 163 Xianlin Avenue, Qixia District, Nanjing 210023, China
    2) Library of Northeast Petroleum University, 99 Xuefu Street, Gaoxin District, Daqing 163318, China
  • Received:2019-03-14 Revised:2019-05-25 Online:2019-08-15 Published:2019-08-30

摘要:

【目的】探索期刊评价的价值回归路径,为营造良好的学术环境和期刊出版环境提供参考。【方法】从期刊评价功能异化的表现入手,阐明其给研究人员、学术期刊和学术生态健康发展带来的负面影响,深入剖析产生这些问题的原因,并提出相应的对策。【结果】期刊评价功能异化的原因包括学术评价体系不健全、文章评价方法和技术不成熟,以及将文章评价、期刊评价、学术评价混淆等。【结论】要想实现期刊评价的价值回归,需要明确期刊评价的目的及适用范围,强化“以文评刊”思想并淡化核心期刊的遴选。

关键词: 期刊评价, 核心期刊, 异化, 以文评刊, 回归

Abstract:

[Purposes] This paper aims to explore the value regression path of journal evaluation, and provide reference for creating a good academic environment and journal publishing environment in China. [Methods] Starting from the performance of journal evaluation function alienation, this paper clarified its negative impact on health development of researchers, academic journals, and academic ecology, deeply analyzed the causes of these problems, and proposed the corresponding countermeasures. [Findings] The reasons for the alienation of journal evaluation function include the imperfect academic evaluation system, the immature evaluation method and technology of the article, and the confusion of article evaluation, journal evaluation, and academic evaluation. [Conclusions] In order to realize the value regression of journal evaluation, it is necessary to clarify the purpose and application of journal evaluation,strengthen the idea of evaluating journals by articles, and dilute the selection of core journals.

Key words: Journal evaluation, Core journal, Alienation, Evaluating journal by article, Regression