中国科技期刊研究 ›› 2016, Vol. 27 ›› Issue (9): 943-948. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.201604050278

• 质量建设 • 上一篇    下一篇

科技期刊学术不端防范措施——对江苏省医学科技期刊的调查分析

邓瑶,洪青标,朱宏儒()   

  1. 《中国血吸虫病防治杂志》编辑部,江苏省无锡市梅园杨巷117号江苏省血吸虫病防治研究所 214064
  • 收稿日期:2016-04-05 修回日期:2016-08-04 出版日期:2016-09-15 发布日期:2016-09-15
  • 通讯作者: 朱宏儒 E-mail:zhuhr0322@163.com
  • 作者简介:邓 瑶(0000-0002-8784-6185),硕士,助理研究员,编辑,E-mail: denyy1982@163.com;|洪青标,主任医师,编辑部主任;
  • 基金资助:
    2014年度江苏省期刊协会研究课题(2014JSQKB043)

Precautionary measures for academ ic m isconducts of scientific journals:investigation and analysis ofmedical journals in Jiangsu Province

DENG Yao,HONG Qingbiao,ZHU Hongru()   

  1. Editorial Department of Chinese Journal of Schistosomiasis Control, Jiangsu Institute of Schistosom iasis, Wuxi214064, China
  • Received:2016-04-05 Revised:2016-08-04 Online:2016-09-15 Published:2016-09-15
  • Contact: ZHU Hongru E-mail:zhuhr0322@163.com

摘要:

目的】了解江苏省医学科技期刊学术不端防范措施实施情况,为期刊管理部门、行业协会及学术期刊防范学术不端提供参考。【方法】设计《江苏省医学科技期刊学术不端防范措施问卷调查表》,通过编辑部邮箱及江苏省期刊QQ群等发放并回收问卷。【结果】共发放47份问卷,回收39份,问卷回收率为82.97%。39种期刊均制订了相关制度,在收稿、送审等环节均采取了相应防范措施,但存在参差不齐的现象。建立同学科期刊信息通报制度、开展多次查重以及联用搜索引擎进一步查重的期刊比例较低,且相关惩罚措施力度尚不够大。【结论】江苏省医学科技期刊在制度建设、查重方式及惩戒措施等方面还需进一步加强和完善。一方面,期刊间应互相借鉴经验和做法;另一方面,期刊行政主管部门及期刊学(协)会亦可适当加以督促和引导。

关键词: 学术不端, 防范措施, 医学科技期刊

Abstract:

[Purposes]This paper aims to understand the precautionary measures for academ ic m isconducts adopted by the medical journals in Jiangsu Province, so as to provide evidence for the periodical adm inistrative departments, industry associations and academ ic journals to prevent academ icmisconducts.[Methods]By literature review,the Questionnaire of Precautionary Measures for Academic Misconducts of Medical Journals in Jiangsu Province was designed,then issued to the editorial departments of related journals and recycled through E-mail and the QQ group of journals in Jiangsu Province.[Findings]We totally issued 47 questionnaires and recycled 39 ones,w ith a recovery rate of 82.97%.Though all39 journals adopted related precautionarymeasures in the course of manuscript processing, such as receiving, peer review ing, but there was an uneven phenomenon among them.The proportions of the journals establishing information reporting system,checking duplicate repeatedly or checking combined w ith search engineswere low.Moreover,the intensity of the punishmentmeasures adopted by the journals and their deterrence should still be strengthened.[Conclusions]For precautionary of academ ic m isconduct,the medical journals in Jiangsu Province should reinforce the institutional building, duplicate checking ways, disciplinary measures construction, and so on.On the one hand, the editorial rooms of the journals should strengthen communication and exchanges; on the other hand, the periodical adm inistrative departments and industry associations could adopt suitablemeasures for supervision and guidance.

Key words: Academ ic m isconduct, Precautionary measure, Medical journal