Collaborative communication mechanism of preprint platform and scientific journals in high energy physics

doi:10.11946/cjstp.202211050827

Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals ›› 2023, Vol. 34 ›› Issue (11): 1374-1382. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.202211050827

Previous Articles Next Articles

Collaborative communication mechanism of preprint platform and scientific journals in high energy physics

DONG Hairong¹⁾()(), BIAN Xiaolin²⁾, LIU Jinpeng¹⁾, WU Yuefeng¹⁾, ZHAO Hongming³⁾

1) Editorial Office of Chinese Physics C, 19B Yuquan Road, Shijingshan District, Beijing 100049, China
2) Editorial Office of Radiation Detection Technology and Methods, 19B Yuquan Road, Shijingshan District, Beijing 100049, China
3) Editorial Office of Modern Physics, 19B Yuquan Road, Shijingshan District, Beijing 100049, China

Received:2022-11-05 Revised:2023-08-31 Online:2023-11-15 Published:2023-11-13

高能物理预印本平台和科技期刊协同交流机制研究

董海荣¹⁾()(), 边晓琳²⁾, 刘金鹏¹⁾, 吴岳峰¹⁾, 赵洪明³⁾

1) 《中国物理C》编辑部,北京市石景山区玉泉路19号乙 100049
2) 《辐射探测技术与方法》编辑部,北京市石景山区玉泉路19号乙 100049
3) 《现代物理知识》编辑部,北京市石景山区玉泉路19号乙 100049

作者简介:
董海荣(ORCID:0000-0002-4605-4405),博士,副编审,编辑部主任,E-mail:donghr@ihep.ac.cn;
边晓琳,硕士,编辑部主任;
刘金鹏,硕士,编辑;
吴岳峰,学士,编辑
赵洪明,博士,副编审,编辑部主任。
作者贡献声明: 董海荣:提出研究方向,设计论文框架,撰写论文; 边晓琳:调研与整理文献,撰写论文; 刘金鹏,吴岳峰:调研与整理文献; 赵洪明:提出研究方向,设计论文框架。
基金资助:
中国科学院自然科学期刊编辑研究会2022年研究课题“高能物理领域预印本平台发展对科技期刊与预印本平台协同共赢的启示”(YJH202208)

Abstract

Abstract:

[Purposes] This paper aims to explore the collaborative communication mechanism between scientific journals and the preprint platform by analyzing and comparing the functions of the representative arXiv preprint platform and scientific journals in high energy physics in academic communication systems. [Methods] Literature research and status quo investigation were adopted to conduct a comparison between the platform and scientific journals in high energy physics in terms of dissemination speed, academic evaluation, paper citation and utilization, open access, and operation modes to analyze their positioning and role in academic communications. [Findings] Scientific journals and preprint platforms have their own strengths and limitations. As important tools for academic communications, they should be mutually complementary and beneficial to create an ideal collaborative communication mechanism for the academic community. [Conclusions] In recent years, preprint platforms have been fast evolving, impacting scientific journals to a certain extent. Thus, we should grasp opportunities to explore new cooperation paths in policy alignment, citation statistics, and open access to achieve win-win collaboration.

Key words: Preprint platform, Scientific journal, Collaborative communication

摘要：

【目的】 通过对比分析高能物理领域具有代表性的arXiv预印本平台和科技期刊在学术交流体系中功能的异同,探索科技期刊与预印本平台的协同交流机制。【方法】 通过文献调研和现状调研的方法对高能物理领域预印本平台和科技期刊在传播速度、学术评价、论文引用和使用、开放获取和运营模式等方面进行比较,分析二者在学术交流中的定位和作用。【结果】 科技期刊与预印本平台具有各自的优势和局限,作为学术交流的重要工具,应当在各方面互利互补,共同为学界打造理想的协同交流机制。【结论】 近年来预印本平台发展迅猛,给科技期刊的发展带来了一定的冲击,我们应当抓住机遇,在政策接轨、引用统计、开放获取等方面探索新的合作途径,协同共赢。

关键词: 预印本平台, 科技期刊, 协同交流

DONG Hairong, BIAN Xiaolin, LIU Jinpeng, WU Yuefeng, ZHAO Hongming. Collaborative communication mechanism of preprint platform and scientific journals in high energy physics[J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(11): 1374-1382.

董海荣, 边晓琳, 刘金鹏, 吴岳峰, 赵洪明. 高能物理预印本平台和科技期刊协同交流机制研究[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2023, 34(11): 1374-1382.

/ / Recommend / Download Citations

URL: https://www.cjstp.cn/EN/10.11946/cjstp.202211050827

https://www.cjstp.cn/EN/Y2023/V34/I11/1374

Figures/Tables 5

References 38

[1]	Johansson M A, Reich N G, Meyers L A, et al. Preprints: An underutilized mechanism to accelerate outbreak science[J]. PLoS Medicine, 2018, 15(4):e1002549. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1002549 URL
[2]	McKeehan L W. The crystal structure of silver-palladium and silver-gold alloys[J]. Physical Review, 1922, 20(5):424-432. doi: 10.1103/PhysRev.20.424 URL
[3]	O'Connell H B. Physicists thriving with paperless publishing[EB/OL]. (2000-07-13)[2022-07-10]. https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0007040. URL
[4]	Goldschmidt-Clermont. Communication patterns in high-energy physics[EB/OL] [2022-07-10]. http://eprints.rclis.org/4253/1/communication_patterns.pdf. URL
[5]	Ginsparg P. First steps towards electronic research communication[J]. Computers in Physics, 1994, 8(4):390-396. doi: 10.1063/1.4823313 URL
[6]	Gunnarsdóttir K. Scientific journal publications:On the role of electronic preprint exchange in the distribution of scientific literature[J]. Social Studies of Science, 2005, 35(4):549-579. doi: 10.1177/0306312705052358 URL
[7]	Joanne Cohn. Joanne Cohn and the email list that led to arXiv[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://pubs.aip.org/physicstoday/Online/29310/Joanne-Cohn-and-the-email-list-that -led-to-arXiv. URL
[8]	Knorr-Cetina K. Epistemic cultures:How the sciences make knowledge[M]. Cambridge: Harvard University Press,1999.
[9]	Xie B Y, Shen Z H, Wang K S. Is preprint the future of science? A thirty year journey of online preprint services[EB/OL]. (2021-02-17)[2022-07-10]. https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.09066. URL
[10]	Garisto D. ArXiv.org reaches a milestone and a reckoning[EB/OL]. (2022-01-10)[2022-07-10]. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/arxiv-org-reaches-a-milestone-and-a-reckoning/. URL
[11]	Ginsparg P. Lessons from arXiv's 30 years of information sharing[J]. Nature Reviews Physics, 2021, 3(9):602-603. doi: 10.1038/s42254-021-00360-z
[12]	Brown C. The E-volution of preprints in the scholarly communication of physicists and astronomers[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2001, 52(3):187-200. doi: 10.1002/(ISSN)1532-2890 URL
[13]	arXiv[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://arxiv.org/help/availability. URL
[14]	Powell K. Does it take too long to publish research?[J]. Nature, 2016, 530(7589):148-151. doi: 10.1038/530148a
[15]	Larivière V, Sugimoto C R, Macaluso B, et al. arXiv E-prints and the journal of record:An analysis of roles and relationships[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2014, 65(6):1157-1169. doi: 10.1002/asi.2014.65.issue-6 URL
[16]	Brown C M. Information seeking behavior of scientists in the electronic information age:Astronomers,chemists,mathematicians,and physicists[J]. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 1999, 50(10):929-943. doi: 10.1002/(ISSN)1097-4571 URL
[17]	Davis P M, Fromerth M J. Does the arXiv lead to higher citations and reduced publisher downloads for mathematics articles?[J]. Scientometrics, 2007, 71(2):203-215. doi: 10.1007/s11192-007-1661-8 URL
[18]	Gentil-Beccot A, Mele S, Brooks T C. Citing and reading behaviours in high-energy physics[J]. Scientometrics, 2010, 84(2):345-355. doi: 10.1007/s11192-009-0111-1 URL
[19]	INSPRIE[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://inspirehep.net/journals/1613955?ui-citation-summary=true. URL
[20]	Brooks T C. Organizing a research community with SPIRES:Where repositories,scientists and publishers meet[J]. Information Services & Use, 2010, 29(2/3):91-96.
[21]	Klein M, Broadwell P, Farb S E, et al. Comparing published scientific journal articles to their pre-print versions[J]. International Journal on Digital Libraries, 2019, 20(4):335-350. doi: 10.1007/s00799-018-0234-1
[22]	Self-archiving FAQ[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. http://www.eprints.org/openaccess/self-faq. URL
[23]	Ginsparg P. Greeting a global knowledge network[C]// Invited contribution for Conference held at UNESCO HQ, February 19-23,2001, Paris. Paris: ICSU Press, 2001.
[24]	Fry J, Spezi V, Probets S, et al. Towards an understanding of the relationship between disciplinary research cultures and open access repository behaviors[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2016, 67(11):2710-2724. doi: 10.1002/asi.2016.67.issue-11 URL
[25]	Mabe M. The E-resource management handbook[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://www.uksg.org/publications/ermh. URL
[26]	arXiv[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://info.arxiv.org/help/bib_feed.html. URL
[27]	Web of Science[EB/OL] [2023-06-10]. https://www.webofscience.com/wos/pprn/basic-search. URL
[28]	COPE Council. COPE discussion document:preprints[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://publicationethics.org/resources/discussion-documents/preprints. URL
[29]	Is F1000Research a preprint server?[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://f1000research.com/faqs. URL
[30]	Quantum journal instructions[EB/OL]. [2022-7-10]. https://quantum-journal.org/instructions/authors/ URL
[31]	赵洪明, 沈彭年. 由欧洲核子研究中心发起的OA计划:粒子物理开放存取出版联盟[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2009, 20(1):17-21.
[32]	解贺嘉, 刘筱敏. 预印本平台开放评议运行模式实证研究[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2021, 32(10):1227-1233. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.202107050535
[33]	边晓琳, 董海荣, 吴岳峰, 等. 科技期刊与预印本平台协同发展的典型模式探讨[J]. 中国科技期刊研究, 2023, 34(7):834-840. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.202211130859
[34]	Journal of high energy physics[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://jhep.sissa.it/jhep/help/helpLoader.jsp?pgType=author. URL
[35]	Research square[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://www.researchsquare.com/. URL
[36]	ESSOAr is here[EB/OL]. [2022-07-10]. https://liemohnjgrspace.wordpress.com. URL
[37]	杨硕. 预印本库与传统期刊合作的典型模式研究[J]. 科技与出版, 2020(7):130-136.
[38]	First Look[EB/OL]. [2020-02-20]. https://wwwelsevier.com/solutions/ssrn/institutional-value/first-look. URL

预印本平台	用户身份审核	格式完整性审核	内容学术性和真实性审核
arXiv	在arXiv平台上注册账户必须有正式机构邮箱,此外还需要通过用户担保制验证,即必须由已经通过验证并在某个领域发表过一定数量论文的用户担保	论文要素完整,符合一般学术要求;论文不能有水印、其他数据库的链接	学术内容原创性及创新性,是否有研究意义
bioRxiv	不作审核	是否包含完整信息、特殊字符拼写是否正确、作者列表是否正确	是否含有危害公众的内容,是否含有攻击性或违背科学性的内容
ResearchSquare	不作审核	论文要素完整,英文表达能力是否过关;是否包含适当的伦理及授权声明,是否声明利益冲突;是否包含病人标识符	不适当、震惊的、极具争议或伪科学的观点、缺乏完全数据论证的极强结论论文,是否包含必须经过同行评议确认才能发表的说法
Preprints	不作审核	未详细说明	基本的科学内容、作者背景、学术道德标准
ChinaXiv	上传者需具备研究身份	自动检查论文完整性,辅以人工审核	具备科学性和创新性,具有一定学术水平和发布价值;是否有不当言论或伪科学内容

预印本平台	用户身份审核	格式完整性审核	内容学术性和真实性审核
arXiv	在arXiv平台上注册账户必须有正式机构邮箱,此外还需要通过用户担保制验证,即必须由已经通过验证并在某个领域发表过一定数量论文的用户担保	论文要素完整,符合一般学术要求;论文不能有水印、其他数据库的链接	学术内容原创性及创新性,是否有研究意义
bioRxiv	不作审核	是否包含完整信息、特殊字符拼写是否正确、作者列表是否正确	是否含有危害公众的内容,是否含有攻击性或违背科学性的内容
ResearchSquare	不作审核	论文要素完整,英文表达能力是否过关;是否包含适当的伦理及授权声明,是否声明利益冲突;是否包含病人标识符	不适当、震惊的、极具争议或伪科学的观点、缺乏完全数据论证的极强结论论文,是否包含必须经过同行评议确认才能发表的说法
Preprints	不作审核	未详细说明	基本的科学内容、作者背景、学术道德标准
ChinaXiv	上传者需具备研究身份	自动检查论文完整性,辅以人工审核	具备科学性和创新性,具有一定学术水平和发布价值;是否有不当言论或伪科学内容

Please choose a citation manager

Content to export

Collaborative communication mechanism of preprint platform and scientific journals in high energy physics

高能物理预印本平台和科技期刊协同交流机制研究

RichHTML

PDF

Knowledge

Cited

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 5

References 38

Related Articles 15

Recommended Articles

Metrics

Comments

[1]	LIU Jingjing, LI Xinren, TIAN Hong. Thoughts on the construction of world-class scientific journals in China in the context of Chinese-style modernization [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(9): 1097-1103.
[2]	YANG Ming, LI Peiying, ZHANG Weiyu, CAO Linxiang. Collaborative relation of scientists' spirit, young technological talents, and scientific journals [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(9): 1104-1110.
[3]	LI Tongtong, XU Yizhen, REN Yangang. Needs, difficulties, and countermeasures of journal cluster construction in universities: Based on in-depth interviews in a university [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(9): 1168-1173.
[4]	WANG Qi, QIAO Yuanbo, ZHANG Ning, SONG Peiyan, LIU Jinting, GUO Jian. Exploration of terminology reviewing mechanism of Chinese scientific journals assisted by proofreading software [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(9): 1174-1179.
[5]	ZHOU Huaqing, LIN Long, HE Jiazi, YU Chenxi. Evaluation index construction and operation strategy of academic short video operation of scientific journals [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(9): 1180-1188.
[6]	MENG Li, CHEN Shuqiang, SHI Jing, ZHOU Ziyi, DUAN Chunbo, YU Pulin. Promoting the differentiated development of medical comprehensive scientific journals: Comparison of column construction among geriatrics-related discipline journals [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(9): 1202-1212.
[7]	HAN Lei, XU Xueyou, LANG Weifeng, LI Qingde, LU Xin, TIAN Xueying, SHI Bin. A survey of the current situation of review process of scientific journals in China [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 1000-1006.
[8]	PANG Li, WANG Lipeng, ZHENG Chunyu, CHEN Jie. Review of text and data mining with AI technology in scientific journals [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 1007-1013.
[9]	LI Tongtong, GAO Ruijing, TIAN Jia. Applicability of ChatGPT in text editing of abstracts for Chinese scientific journals [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 1014-1019.
[10]	HU Qian, WANG Jiayun, CHEN Yiben. Practical prospect and future approach of digital transformation of scientific journals under metaverse situation [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 1020-1028.
[11]	GAO Hong, ZHANG Zhiqiang. Professional loyalty of scientific journal editors: Realistic level, internal mechanism, and cultivation strategy [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 1045-1053.
[12]	JIANG Yuyan, WANG Liyun, LIU Xueli. Innovative evaluation of Chinese SCIE-indexed scientific journals: An empirical study based on the disruption index [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 1060-1068.
[13]	MENG Li, SHI Jing, CHEN Shuqiang, ZHOU Baiyu, LI Jiawei, ZHOU Ziyi, DUAN Chunbo, YU Pulin. Publishing characteristics and academic influence of overseas comprehensive geriatric journals and implications [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 1078-1087.
[14]	MENG Shengjun, YANG Qingyi, LI Yanni, LIU Chen. Influencing factors and governance strategies of improper signing behavior in scientific journals from the perspective of bounded rationality [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 967-974.
[15]	ZHOU Huaqing, WU Hongdan. Identification and management of plagiarism in short science videos from the perspective of scientific journals [J]. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2023, 34(8): 975-981.