【目的】总结疑似第三方代投稿件的特征,提出防范策略。【方法】提取《中国普外基础与临床杂志》自使用投稿与审稿系统至2017年7月31日投稿邮箱地址以tg、tgyx 及yxtg 结尾稿件的相关数据,并对稿件进行统计学分析。【结果】共检索出相关稿件440篇,逐篇阅读稿件,综合各方面特征,最终将431篇稿件纳入统计学分析。分析结果表明:第三方代投形势严峻,在投稿时无针对性,广投、滥投;论文的著作权归属不明确,且投稿者联系电话归属地和单位所在地往往不一致。【结论】编辑需不断提升自身素养,多角度查证疑似第三方代投稿件。
[Purposes] This study aims to sum up the features of papers submitted by the third party, and propose preventive strategies. [Methods] Data of papers which were submitted by the third party based on certain characteristics, such as ending with tg, tgyx, and yxtg in the E-mail addresses were collected to analyze the features, and the deadline was July 31, 2017. [Findings] A total of 431 papers were enrolled while the other 9 papers were excluded after comprehensive evaluation. The analysis results show the situation of papers submitted by the third party is severe. The third party submits papers without any definite purposes, so its behavior involves a lot of journals. In addition, there are no signed authors in papers, and the location sites of telephone numbers are often inconsistent with the location sites of affiliations registered in the system. [Conclusions] For distinguishing the papers submitted by the third part from normal papers, the editors should constantly upgrade their attainments and find various evidence.
Papers submitted by the third party,