Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals ›› 2025, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (9): 1188-1197. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.202505090482

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Construction of the Hall’s three-dimensional model for the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals and strategies for enhancing the three-dimensional factors

ZHENG Xiaomei1),2)()(), YANG Guihua3), TU Jian4), YU Hai5)   

  1. 1) Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences,Chinese Academy of Sciences,18 Shuangqing Road,Haidian District,Beijing 100085,China
    2) Beijing Lunke Culture Co. ,Ltd. ,1 Disheng North Street,Daxing District,Beijing 100176,China
    3) Editorial Department of Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae,Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences,Chinese Academy of Sciences,18 Shuangqing Road,Haidian District,Beijing 100085,China
    4) Editorial Department of Acta Medicae Sinica,Guilin Medical University,1 Zhiyuan Road,Lingui District,Guilin 541199,China
    5) Editorial Department of Journal of Liaoning Normal Colleges(Natural Science Edition),Chaoyang Normal University,966 Sec. 4 Longshan Street,Shuangta District,Chaoyang 122000,China
  • Received:2025-05-09 Online:2025-09-25 Published:2025-10-28

科技期刊编校质量霍尔三维模型构建及三维因素提升策略

郑晓梅1),2)()(), 杨桂华3), 涂剑4), 于海5)   

  1. 1) 中国科学院生态环境研究中心,北京市海淀区双清路18号 100085
    2) 北京论科文化有限责任公司,北京市大兴区地盛北街1号 100176
    3) 中国科学院生态环境研究中心《环境科学学报》编辑部,北京市海淀区双清路18号 100085
    4) 桂林医科大学《华夏医学》编辑部,广西桂林市临桂区致远路1号 541199
    5) 朝阳师范学院《辽宁师专学报(自然科学版)》编辑部,辽宁省朝阳市双塔区龙山街四段966号 122000
  • 作者简介:

    郑晓梅(ORCID:0000-0002-1462-9083),硕士,编审,E-mail:

    杨桂华,硕士,副编审,《环境科学学报》编辑部主任

    涂 剑,博士,教授,博士研究生导师,《华夏医学》常务副主编,编辑部主任

    于 海,博士,副编审,《辽宁师专学报(自然科学版)》主编。

    作者贡献声明: 郑晓梅:提出研究问题,设计论文框架,查阅、整理、调研文献,起草、修改论文; 杨桂华:设计论文框架,查阅、整理、调研文献,参与起草、修改论文; 涂 剑:搜集资料,修改并审定论文; 于 海:调研文献,修改并审定论文。
  • 基金资助:
    韬奋基金会2025年度课题“人工智能技术影响下学术期刊编辑核心能力体系重塑研究”(TF2025071); 高等教育出版社-辽宁省期刊协会科技期刊高质量发展研究与实践课题(LJA2024-GJ-028)

Abstract:

Purposes To comprehensively and systematically explore strategies for enhancing the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals, scientifically and accurately disseminate excellent scientific research achievements, and promote the high-quality development of scientific journals. Methods By combining the Hall’s three-dimensional model with the practice of editing and publishing scientific journals, and utilizing the theory of the Hall’s three-dimensional model, we systematically analyzed the current status of the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals and the three-dimensional influencing factors. We identified the correspondence between the three-dimensional factors of the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals and the “three dimensions” in the Hall’s three-dimensional model, and outlined the concepts and characteristics of the Hall’s three-dimensional model for the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals. Findings We constructed a Hall’s three-dimensional model for the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals; clarified the concepts of the Hall’s three-dimensional model for the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals, and summarized its four characteristics; and explored three-dimensional improvement strategies for the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals from three dimensions: professional knowledge and skills, time nodes and stages, and journal publishing processes. Conclusions The constructed Hall’s three-dimensional model for the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals treats the three-dimensional factors affecting the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals as a whole system, emphasizing the integrity, systematicness, and unity of the system, and comprehensively considering the balance and coordination of various factors, thereby achieving the effect of enhancing the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals. The research results can provide references for scientific journal managers, editors, and other relevant personnel in controlling the editing and proofreading quality and formulating strategies for enhancing the editing and proofreading quality of scientific journals.

Key words: Scientific journals, Editing and proofreading quality, Hall’s three-dimensional model, Professional knowledge and skills dimension, Time nodes and stages dimension, Journal publishing processes dimension, Three-dimensional factors

摘要:

目的 为全面系统探讨科技期刊编校质量提升策略,科学、准确传播优秀科研成果,促进科技期刊高质量发展。方法 将霍尔三维模型与科技期刊编辑出版实践相结合,借助霍尔三维模型理论,系统梳理科技期刊编校质量现状及三维影响因素,找出科技期刊编校质量三维因素与霍尔三维模型中“三维”的对应关系,梳理科技期刊编校质量霍尔三维模型的概念及特点。结果 构建科技期刊编校质量霍尔三维模型;明确科技期刊编校质量霍尔三维模型的概念并总结科技期刊编校质量霍尔三维模型的特点;从专业知识和技能、时间节点阶段、期刊出版环节3个维度探讨科技期刊编校质量三维因素提升策略。结论 构建的科技期刊编校质量霍尔三维模型将影响科技期刊编校质量的三维因素作为一个整体系统来看待,强调系统的整体性、系统性、统一性,综合考虑各因素的平衡协调,从而实现科技期刊编校质量提升。研究结果可为科技期刊管理人员及编辑等相关人员控制编校质量和制定科技期刊编校质量提升策略提供参考。

关键词: 科技期刊, 编校质量, 霍尔三维模型, 专业知识和技能维度, 时间节点阶段维度, 期刊出版环节维度, 三维因素