Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals ›› 2022, Vol. 33 ›› Issue (7): 844-851. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.202110070770

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comparison of international reputation of domestic English scientific journals on seven disciplines

HUANG Kun1)()(), LIN Liying2),*()(), GUO Miao1), YOU Bin2)   

  1. 1) School of Government, Beijing Normal University, 19 Xinjiekouwai Street, Haidian District, Beijing 100875, China
    2) China National Publications Import and Export (Group) Co., Ltd., 16 Gongti East Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100020, China
  • Received:2021-10-07 Revised:2022-04-10 Online:2022-07-15 Published:2022-08-25
  • Contact: LIN Liying E-mail:huangkun@bnu.edu.cn;linliying@cnpiec.com.cn

国内7个学科英文科技期刊国际声誉调查与比较

黄崑1)()(), 林丽颖2),*()(), 郭淼1), 尤斌2)   

  1. 1)北京师范大学政府管理学院,北京市海淀区新街口外大街19号 100875
    2)中国图书进出口(集团)总公司,北京市朝阳区工体东路16号 100020
  • 通讯作者: 林丽颖 E-mail:huangkun@bnu.edu.cn;linliying@cnpiec.com.cn
  • 作者简介:黄 崑(ORCID:0000-0003-0850-7263),博士,教授,E-mail: huangkun@bnu.edu.cn
    郭 淼,硕士研究生;尤 斌,硕士,数字编辑,科长。

Abstract:

[Purposes] This paper investigates the international reputation of Scopus-indexed domestic English scientific journals to explore strategies for the development of world leading journals. [Methods] With online questionnaire, we probed into the reputation of the English journals on seven disciplines from six aspects: general impression, journal papers, publishing service and performance, journal team, objectives and management, and social responsibility. A total of 643 valid responses of seven disciplines were recovered and compared. [Findings] The difference in the overall reputation evaluation among the seven disciplines is not significant. However, the English journals on agriculture and biological science, materials science, and earth and planetary science achieve higher awareness, recognition, academic contribution, and application value. [Conclusions] The domestic English scientific journals on all the seven disciplines need to improve the awareness, recognition, and media exposure. English journals of dominant disciplines should strive to attract domestic high-level research outcomes and enhance international awareness and recognition. English scientific journals on subdominant disciplines should raise paper quality and international awareness. In addition, it is necessary to improve scientific research evaluation measures and systems, guide the development of domestic English scientific journals, and develop better academic environment.

Key words: Journal reputation, International reputation, Discipline comparison, Journal evaluation, English scientific journal

摘要:

【目的】 调查国际科研人员对我国入选Scopus的英文科技期刊的声誉评价,探索世界一流期刊建设对策。【方法】 通过在线问卷调查,从一般印象、期刊论文、出版服务与业绩、办刊团队、目标与管理、社会责任6个方面考察国际同行对我国英文科技期刊的主观感知,对7个学科的643份有效回收问卷进行比较分析。【结果】 7个学科的整体声誉评价结果差异不显著,但是农业与生物科学、材料科学、地球与行星科学在领域知晓、领域认可、学术贡献与应用价值的部分指标上获得的评分更高。【结论】 7个学科的英文科技期刊整体都需要提升领域知晓度、认可度和媒体曝光度。优势学科英文科技期刊进一步加强吸引国内高水平成果,提升国际知晓度和认可度;次优势学科英文科技期刊提升论文学术质量和国际可见性。期刊管理部门应进一步健全科研评价措施和制度,引导国内英文科技期刊健康发展,建立良好学术生态环境。

关键词: 期刊声誉, 国际声誉, 学科比较, 期刊评价, 英文科技期刊