Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals

Impact of Chinese peer review comment characteristics on paper citation frequency： taking review comments from Acta Psychologica Sinica as an example

CHEN Junhui, ZHANG Lihua, XIA Qianjie

Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2026, 37(1): 160-170. DOI: 10.11946/cjstp.202510031182

变量维度	变量名称	类别	样本量/条	比例/%
论文本体特征	Fund	是	62784	95.84
	Fund	否	2725	4.16
	Prest_affil	是	36350	55.49
	Prest_affil	否	29159	44.51
	Insti_collab	是	40003	61.06
	Insti_collab	否	25506	38.93
评审意见内容特征	Editor	是	39281	59.96
	Editor	否	26228	40.04
	Review	Rev_1	16074	24.54
		Rev_2	17159	26.19
		Rev_3	9790	14.94
		Rev_4	10733	16.38
		Rev_5	11753	17.94

Table 4 Descriptive statistics of categorical variables

Other figure/table from this article

Figure 1 Research framework for the impact of peer review comment characteristics on citation frequency
Table 1 Variable description
Table 2 Classification criteria for peer review comments
Table 3 Descriptive statistics of continuous variables
Table 5 Correlation analysis between continuous variables and citation frequency
Table 6 Baseline regression results