中国科技期刊研究 ›› 2016, Vol. 27 ›› Issue (9): 975-980. doi: 10.11946/cjstp.201603210229

• 评价与分析 • 上一篇    下一篇

国际期刊撤销论文分布特征以及对我国期刊出版的启示

付中静1,2)   

  1. 1)新乡医学院期刊社《眼科新进展》编辑部,河南省新乡市金穗大道601号 453003
    2)河南省科技期刊研究中心,河南省新乡市金穗大道601号 453003
  • 收稿日期:2016-03-21 修回日期:2016-05-31 出版日期:2016-09-15 发布日期:2016-09-15
  • 作者简介:付中静(ORCID:0000-0002-6933-3992),编辑,期刊社办公室副主任,E-mail: fuzhongjing11@163.com
  • 基金资助:
    河南省高等学校哲学社会科学基础研究重大项目(2015-JCZD-013)

Analysis of the phenomenon of self-correction of international journals And its inspiration to periodicals publishing in our country

FU Zhongjing1,2)   

  1. 1) Editorial Office of Recent Advances in Ophthalmology, Xinxiang Medical University, 601 JinsuiRoad, Xinxiang 453003, China
    2) Henan Research Center for Scientific Journals, Xinxiang Medical University, 601 Jinsui Road, Xinxiang 453003, China
  • Received:2016-03-21 Revised:2016-05-31 Online:2016-09-15 Published:2016-09-15

摘要:

目的】探讨Web of Science(WoS)数据库撤销论文的分布特征,以期对我国的科技期刊管理提出建议。【方法】分析2004—2013年撤销论文的数量、撤销时滞和期刊的IF以及不同国家的撤销论文数量和H指数之间的相关性;并分组比较撤销论文的撤销时滞。【结果】期刊的IF与撤销论文数量正相关(P=0.036),与撤销时滞不相关(P=0.709)。2004—2008年、2009—2013年的撤销时滞差异显著(P=0.000)。国家H指数与撤销论文数量正相关(P=0.002)。【结论】高H指数国家、高IF期刊撤销论文数量较多,撤销时滞与期刊IF不相关。国内期刊自我净化氛围缺失,需要广大期刊编辑和同行评审专家以及读者加强监督。

关键词: 撤销论文, IF, 撤销时滞, 国家H指数

Abstract:

[Purposes]We searched the retracted articleswhich were obtained from theWeb of Science(WoS) in nearly ten years,and summarized their characteristics,in order to provide a reference for Chinese scientific journals publishing policy.[Methods]The statistical analysis of data of the retracted articleswhich were obtained from theWoS,was carried out to test correlation among journals'impact factor, the number of retracted articles, and their time-to-retraction; an analysis of the correlation between H-index of countries and the number of retracted articleswas alsomade.[Findings]The correlation between journals'impact factor and the number of retracted articles showed a significant association (P=0.036); there was no correlation between journals'impact factor and time-to-retraction(P=0.709).Country-based H-index and the number of retracted articles had a significant association(P=0.002).Time-to-retraction (from 2004-2008) had correlation w ith time-to-retraction (from 2004-2008) (P=0.000).[Conclusions]The higher country-based H-index and higher journals'impact factor,themore retracted articles exist.There was no correlation between journals'impact factor and time-to-retraction.Recommendations for domestic and foreign databases on the retracted articles label standardization was put forward.Domestic journals lack the self-purification atmosphere,which requires the majority of journal editors and peer review experts as well as readers to strengthen supervision.

Key words: Retracted article, Impact factor, Time-to-retraction, Country-based H-index